- NBR - The National Bureau of Asian Research

NBR Analysis

The NBR Analysis offers thought-provoking essays and briefs on the most important economic, political, and strategic issues in the Asia-Pacific region today.

NBR Analysis (May 1998)

Political Legacies and Prospects for Democratic Development in Southeast Asia:

Mary P. Callahan and Donald K. Emmerson

This issue of the NBR Analysis focuses on two Southeast Asian nationsIndonesia and Burmathat pose complex challenges to U.S. policymakers. Burma’s military regime, recently renamed the State Peace and Development Committee (SPDC), remains in firm control of the country, despite U.S. efforts to isolate and unseat it. In Indonesia, the economic crisis and concerns about political instability have raised important questions about the most appropriate ways to channel humanitarian and development assistance to the beleaguered economy and to encourage political reform. In the pages that follow, two of America’s leading scholars on Southeast Asia offer rich historical perspective on the contemporary political landscapes of these countries.

In the first essay, Dr. Mary Callahan, assistant professor of national security affairs at the Naval Postgraduate School, addresses the political and socioeconomic conditions that obstructed Burma’s democratic development in the 1950s and are still very much a factor today. These barriers include: (1) the inadequate political basis for federalism in the multiethnic country; (2) a crisis of state capacity rooted in the fragmented nature of Burmese society; and (3) an institutional intolerance of dissent on the part of authoritarian and pro-democracy organizations alike. She points out that current U.S. policy does little to address these hurdles, and until they are overcome it is unlikely that democratic government could be sustained in Burmaeven if efforts to unseat the ruling junta were successful. Moreover, Dr. Callahan argues that the "all-or-nothing" approach of the United States, which focuses on deposing the military government, raises the cost of conciliation for all parties and leaves the ruling junta with little incentive to negotiate.

Professor Donald Emmerson of the University of Wisconsin-Madison turns to the political question of presidential succession in Indonesia. He notes the likelihood that medical or political circumstances may prevent President Soeharto from completing the five-year term to which he was re-elected in March 1998. Through a careful examination of constitutional and historical evidence, Professor Emmerson argues that the vaguely worded, yet symbolically powerful 1945 constitution will establish important parameters for the succession process. The U.S. should neither isolate nor embrace Indonesia’s controversial president, the author concludes, but should seek bilateral and multilateral channels of assistance to those least responsible for the economic crisis and least able to withstand its effects.

Table of Contents

Democracy in Burma: The Lessons of History
Mary P. Callahan

Indonesia's Coming Succession: Constitutional Text, Historical Context, and Recommendations for U.S. Policy in a Time of Crisis
Donald K. Emmerson

Back Issues

The Dilemma Confronting the U.S.-Thailand Relationship
Pavin Chachavalpongpun
(Apr 16)

Strengthening Transatlantic Policy Coordination on Asia
Nadège Rolland and Michael Wills
(Feb 16)

The New China-Russia-U.S. Triangle
Elizabeth Wishnick
(Dec 15)

What to Do about North Korea
Sue Mi Terry
(Nov 15)

Shinzo Abe and the Reality of Japanese Democracy
Daniel Sneider
(Aug 15)

U.S.-Malaysia Relations on the Security Front
Pamela Sodhy
(Apr 15)

The Trans-Pacific Partnership: Lessons from Negotiations
Richard Katz
(Sep 14)

Responding to China’s Assertiveness in the South China Sea
James R. Holmes
(Jun 14)

The Sea Change in Japanese Foreign Policy
Kenneth B. Pyle
(Jun 14)

Beyond Haiyan: Toward Greater U.S.-Japan Cooperation in HADR
Weston S. Konishi and Andrew L. Oros
(Feb 14)

Japan-Korea Relations: Time for U.S. Intervention?
Daniel Sneider
(Jan 14)

China’s Growth Slowdown and Its Implications
Dwight H. Perkins
(Nov 13)

The ASEAN Regional Forum: Beyond the Talk Shop?
Sheldon W. Simon
(Jul 13)

Will Abenomics Restore Japanese Growth?
William W. Grimes
(Jun 13)

The State of Cooperation in the East China Sea
James Manicom
(Apr 13)

Whose Pacific Century? The 113th Congress and Asia
Edward Gresser and Daniel Twining
(Apr 13)

Intensifying Contradictions: Chinese Policing Enters the 21st Century
Jonathan Walton
(Feb 13)

The Impending Tide of Chinese Investment in the United States
Robert A. Kapp
(Feb 13)

The Leap in North Korea’s Ballistic Missile Program: The Iran Factor
John S. Park
(Dec 12)

Northeast Asia Turns Its Attention to the Arctic
Linda Jakobson
(Dec 12)